Skip to main content

Supreme Eats Pizza and Pasta
$$$ · Pizza

1590 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10029
Are you the owner? Claim this business

ZipPicks Awards

Best Pizza in East Harlem

Vibe Check this spot

Food Quality 5
Service 5
Atmosphere 5
Value 5
Consistency 5
Cultural Relevance 5

0 / 5 selected

Master Critic Review

Supreme Eats Pizza and Pasta 7.9
East Harlem
Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Family Friendly Favorites Group Dining Gatherings Quick Bites Champions
A newer Lexington Avenue spot in a former long-running pizza space, now built around grandma-style squares, stuffed-crust Sicilians, and a fuller Italian menu with salads, wings, and pastas. It’s best when you treat it like a sit-down pizzeria where you share a couple of specialty pies and a starter instead of just grabbing one basic slice.
Must-Try Dishes: Grandma Rainbow MVP Pizza, Stuffed Crust Sicilian Pizza, Homemade Mozzarella Sticks
Scores:
Value: 7.8 Service: 7.7 Consistency: 7.6 Food Quality: 8.4 Atmosphere: 6.2 Cultural Relevance: 6.6
What makes it special: Grandma and stuffed-crust Sicilian pies with a broader Italian menu in a familiar Lexington Avenue dining room.
Who should go: Groups wanting specialty pies and sharable starters
When to visit: Prime dinner hours when the room feels most alive
What to order: Grandma Rainbow MVP, stuffed-crust Sicilian, mozzarella sticks
Insider tip: Mix one classic grandma pie with one more heavily topped specialty to keep the table from getting sauce-heavy.