ZipPicks Awards
Best French Fries in Williamsburg
Best Bagels in Prospect Heights & Clinton Hill
Master Critic Review
Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe
8.3
A Prospect Heights standby for classic, no-gimmick bagels that hit best when they’re fresh and barely touched by the toaster. The menu is deep, but the smart move is one traditional build (lox or egg-and-cheese) plus one specialty sandwich if you’re hungry—then get out while it’s still hot.
Must-Try Dishes:
Everything bagel with lox and cream cheese, Mr. F sandwich on an everything bagel, Pumpernickel everything with veggie-forward schmear
Scores:
Value: 8.4
Service: 7.8
Consistency: 8.6
Food Quality: 8.6
Atmosphere: 6.4
Cultural Relevance: 8.1
What makes it special: Old-school bagel-shop execution with a menu that rewards simple, classic orders.
Who should go: Neighborhood breakfast regulars and lox-and-scallion people
When to visit: Early morning for peak freshness
What to order: Everything bagel with lox, egg-and-cheese, one house sandwich
Insider tip: Skip heavy toasting—fresh bagel texture is the point here.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking only; usually manageable early mornings, tighter late morning on weekends.
Dress code: Very casual—jeans, sneakers, neighborhood errands attire.
Noise level: Moderate during peak hours; fine for conversation but lively when the line is moving.
Weekend wait: Not applicable—primarily a breakfast and lunch spot.
Weekday lunch: No wait to 5 minutes most days; short line during late-morning rush.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes—multiple bagels, cream cheeses, egg-and-cheese, and veggie-based sandwiches.
Vegan options: Limited—plain bagels and a few vegetable spreads; confirm ingredients on specialty items.
Gluten-free options: No—no gluten-free bagels or dedicated prep area.
Best For
Better for: Classic, unfussy bagels with reliable execution and neighborhood pricing.
Skip if: You want trendy cream cheese flavors, big café seating, or a long sit-down brunch experience.