Best Trendy Table Hotspots Japanese Restaurants in Upper West Side (Central)
4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Sushi of Gari - Columbus Avenue
Creative, sauce-driven nigiri and omakase that defined a modern Gari style of sushi.
Notable Picks
Upper West Side outpost of Sushi of Gari, known for topping pristine nigiri with creative sauces and garnishes rather than relying on soy sauce. Locals use it for splurge dinners and special occasions where the omakase leans playful but still focuses squarely on top-tier fish.
Must-Try Dishes:
Tuna Tofu Sushi, Salmon Tomato Sushi, Sushi Omakase
What Makes it Special: Creative, sauce-driven nigiri and omakase that defined a modern Gari style of sushi.
8.4
Tiny omakase counter opened in 2024 offering 9-course lunch and 13-course dinner tastings at a fixed price. The minimalist format and small seating make it a focused experience for diners who want chef-led bites without Midtown formality.
Must-Try Dishes:
9-Course Lunch Omakase, 13-Course Dinner Omakase, A La Carte Extras
What Makes it Special: Small-seat omakase counter focused on tightly paced chef’s tastings.
#3
Omakase 95
8.1
A budget omakase counter on the Upper West Side running tiered tasting menus from $32 to $69, with fish sourced daily from Toyosu Market through the Shihou Group's multi-location supply chain. The format is efficient—75-minute seatings at a clean counter where chefs explain each course and adjust service to individual diners. It fills a specific gap for neighborhood-accessible omakase without the prix-fixe sticker shock, though it's still too new to know if the early momentum holds.
Must-Try Dishes:
Premium Omakase (12 Pcs Sushi, 2 Appetizers, Dessert), Chiba 15-Course Lunch Omakase, Omakase Dinner (10 Pcs Sushi, Appetizer, Dessert)
What Makes it Special: Sub-$100 omakase on the Upper West Side with tiered tasting menus starting at $32, using fresh ingredients sourced daily.
#4
Momoya
8
Vibes:
Group Dining Gatherings
Girls Night Out Approved
Family Friendly Favorites
Trendy Table Hotspots
Lively Japanese restaurant that balances signature rolls, sashimi platters, and kitchen dishes in a modern room just off 81st Street. It’s a go-to on the Upper West Side for groups, dates, and family dinners when you want polished sushi without full omakase formality.
Must-Try Dishes:
Crispy Rice, Momoya Spicy Tuna Roll, Miso Black Cod
What Makes it Special: Stylish, crowd-pleasing sushi spot with signature rolls and full Japanese menu.