Best Date Night Magic Mexican Restaurants in Upper West Side (Central)
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Covacha
Jalisco-focused cooking with Bib Gourmand recognition and serious cocktails.
Notable Picks
#1
Covacha
8.8
Modern Mexican restaurant on the Upper West Side serving Jalisco-inspired ranch cooking with a serious cocktail program. The kitchen leans into slow-cooked moles, barbacoa, and seafood plates that have earned it a Bib Gourmand nod and a steady local following.
Must-Try Dishes:
Mole Dulce Pork Belly Plato, Zarandeado Whole Striped Bass, Guacamole Ashes
What Makes it Special: Jalisco-focused cooking with Bib Gourmand recognition and serious cocktails.
8.3
A lively Upper West Side Mexican room where the menu goes beyond tacos into plates built for a full sit-down dinner. The move is to treat it like a tequila-bar meal: one signature protein, one sauce-forward dish, and a round of strong margaritas to carry the pacing.
Must-Try Dishes:
Chicken mole, Tacos al pastor, Margaritas
What Makes it Special: A tequila-forward Mexican dinner spot with a real “order plates” rhythm.
8
Vibes:
Date Night Magic
Girls Night Out Approved
Trendy Table Hotspots
Birthday & Celebration Central
Polanco Social is a newer kosher Mexican restaurant in the former Thyme & Tonic space, pairing ceviche, tacos, and dishes like ribeye steak with a strong cocktail program. Guests describe a lively, design-forward room where gluten-free options and composed tacos sit closer to upscale dining than quick counter service.
Must-Try Dishes:
Mahi Mahi Taco with Grilled Pineapple, Short Rib Taco, Ceviche with Jalapeño
What Makes it Special: Kosher Mexican spot pairing tacos and ceviche with cocktails and steak.