Best Hidden Gems Heaven Pizza Restaurants in Lenox Hill
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Donna Margherita
Cozy Neapolitan-style trattoria blending brick-oven pizza with homestyle pastas.
Notable Picks
8.4
Donna Margherita is a compact Upper East Side trattoria and wine bar where Neapolitan-style pizzas, pastas, and comfort dishes come out of a brick oven in a mural-lined dining room. The kitchen leans traditional, with spaghetti meatballs, linguine alle vongole, and melanzane alla parmigiana sharing space with signature pies like the Donna Margherita. Warm hospitality from a Naples-rooted team makes it feel more like a neighborhood living room than a formal restaurant.
Must-Try Dishes:
Donna Margherita Pizza, Linguine alle Vongole, Chicken Parmigiana
What Makes it Special: Cozy Neapolitan-style trattoria blending brick-oven pizza with homestyle pastas.
Worthy Picks
7.8
A cozy, local pizza spot on York Avenue offering generously topped pies and creative slice options; a favorite for residents seeking a neighborhood‑centric meal. While its hours aren’t the latest on the block, its pizzas carry a balanced sauce and crust that satisfy late‑dinner cravings. The service is friendly and personal.
Must-Try Dishes:
White Pie, Spicy Pepperoni, Veggie Supreme
What Makes it Special: Resident favorite with creative topping combos.
#3
Frico on 2nd
7.6
A small, highly rated pizza shop on 2nd Avenue that punches above its weight with flavorful pies and a welcoming counter service setup. Its limited review volume suggests a tight‑knit local following. Expect classic combinations and quality ingredients in a casual atmosphere. Noted for its friendly staff and satisfying slices.
Must-Try Dishes:
Classic Cheese Pizza, Prosciutto & Arugula, Mushroom Truffle Slice
What Makes it Special: Flavorful pies with thoughtful topping combos.