Best Bagels Restaurants in Cobble Hill Historic District
2 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Shelsky's of Brooklyn Appetizing & Delicatessen
Bagels pair with serious smoked fish and composed appetizing plates rather than simple deli spreads.
Notable Picks
Shelsky's of Brooklyn is a modern Jewish appetizing shop where hand-rolled bagels become the base for smoked fish, caviar, and composed sandwiches rather than quick grab-and-go snacks. Regulars treat it as a destination for luxe bagel-and-lox builds, whitefish salad, and creative combinations built on in-house cured fish and robust cream cheeses. Prices are higher than a typical bagel counter, but the ingredient quality and depth of flavor justify making it a special weekend stop.
Must-Try Dishes:
Brooklyn Native bagel sandwich with smoked fish, Everything bagel with nova and scallion cream cheese, Bialy or bagel with whitefish salad
What Makes it Special: Bagels pair with serious smoked fish and composed appetizing plates rather than simple deli spreads.
8.2
Vibes:
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Quick Bites Champions
Family Friendly Favorites
Comfort Food Classics
Court Street Bagels is a busy Cobble Hill staple where long bagel cases, schmears, and deli sandwiches fuel the neighborhood from early morning through lunch. Regulars rely on it for chewy bagels with generous spreads, fast-moving lines, and made-to-order breakfast sandwiches that feel very old-school Brooklyn. The interior is cramped and no-frills, but the volume of repeat customers says a lot about value and reliability.
Must-Try Dishes:
Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, Bacon, egg, and cheese on sesame, Nova lox bagel with tomato and red onion
What Makes it Special: High-volume neighborhood bagel counter known for chewy bagels and heavy-handed schmears.