What is the best Bagels restaurant in Chelsea?

ARK Bagels is our top pick for Bagels restaurants in Chelsea, scoring 8.4/10. Wide variety including rainbow bagels and fast friendly service

Best Bagels Restaurants in Chelsea

2 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Save

Our Top Pick

ARK Bagels

Wide variety including rainbow bagels and fast friendly service

#1 ARK Bagels

8.4

$ Chelsea Bagels

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Hidden Gems Heaven

Chewy, colorful bagels with diverse schmears and quick counter service make ARK Bagels a solid grab‑and‑go favorite in Chelsea.

Must-Try Dishes: Everything bagel with sun‑dried tomato cream cheese & lox, Rainbow bagel, Whole wheat everything with classic schmear

What Makes it Special: Wide variety including rainbow bagels and fast friendly service

#2 Modern Bread & Bagel

8.1

$$ Chelsea Bagels

Vibes: Healthy Haven Quick Bites Champions Brunch Bliss Spots Hidden Gems Heaven

Dedicated gluten‑free bagel shop offering hand‑rolled, kettle‑boiled bagels and inventive sandwiches — a reliable stop for allergen‑conscious diners.

Must-Try Dishes: Gluten‑free everything bagel with whipped cream cheese, Egg & cheese breakfast sandwich, Cinnamon‑raisin bagel

What Makes it Special: Exclusively gluten‑free bagels with solid texture, rare among NYC bagel shops