ZipPicks Awards
Best Italian in Williamsburg
Best Pizza in Williamsburg
Master Critic Review
Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn
8.1
Roman pinsa, the multigrain ancestor of pizza, arrives with a puffy interior and crisp edges from imported flour blends. The greenhouse dining room with retractable roof offers year-round outdoor vibes, while traditional cacio e pepe and seasonal specials round out the menu.
Must-Try Dishes:
Maranella Pinsa, Margherita Pinsa, Cacio e Pepe
Scores:
Value: 7.8
Service: 8
Consistency: 8
Food Quality: 8.2
Atmosphere: 8.8
Cultural Relevance: 7.8
What makes it special: NYC's only Roman pinseria with an enclosed garden and retractable glass roof
Who should go: Pizza innovators and winter-brunch seekers
When to visit: Winter evenings for snowglobe dining effect
What to order: Maranella pinsa with stracciatella, suppli
Insider tip: Book the back garden room for private parties up to 30
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking only on Union Ave and side streets; metered spots available but competitive after 6pm in Williamsburg
Dress code: Casual - jeans and sneakers perfectly fine; Williamsburg neighborhood vibe
Noise level: Loud when busy - reviews note difficulty hearing companions during peak hours; greenhouse room amplifies sound
Weekend wait: 15-30 min without reservation; tables often available for last-minute dinner even on weekends
Weekday lunch: No wait typically; walk-ins accommodated easily
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes - multiple options including supplì (rice croquettes), margherita pinsa, melanzane pinsa with eggplant, and pasta dishes
Vegan options: Limited - roasted artichokes with salsa verde, tomato-based pinsas can be modified; ask server for current options
Gluten-free options: Available upon request for pasta dishes; pinsa dough contains wheat (their SF Marina location is fully GF, but Brooklyn is not)
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Excellent choice - The Infatuation lists it as ideal for date nights. The enclosed glass greenhouse creates romantic ambiance with plants and stargazing potential. Go on a weekday or early evening when noise levels are lower for actual conversation.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Usually yes. Even weekends typically have tables for walk-ins. For the back garden greenhouse (the main draw), reservations via OpenTable or Resy help secure prime seating, especially for groups of 4+.
Is it kid-friendly? Reasonable for families with older kids - it's casual with shareable pizza-style food they'll enjoy. The lively weekend brunch crowd skews more adult. High chairs available; wheelchair accessible.
Best For
Better for: Year-round outdoor dining experience without weather worries; group-friendly shareable pinsa format; unique Roman-style pizza you won't find elsewhere in North Brooklyn
Skip if: You want exceptional pasta (critics recommend sticking to pinsa); you need a quiet intimate conversation; you're strictly gluten-free (limited accommodation unlike their SF location)