Skip to main content

Made In New York Pizza
$ · Pizza

421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
Are you the owner? Claim this business

ZipPicks Awards

Best Family Friendly Pizza in Upper West Side Best Cheap Pizza in Upper West Side Best Cheap Eats in Upper West Side Best Pizza in Upper West Side

Vibe Check this spot

Food Quality 5
Service 5
Atmosphere 5
Value 5
Consistency 5
Cultural Relevance 5

0 / 5 selected

Master Critic Review

Made In New York Pizza 8.7
Upper West Side (Central)
Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Late Night Legends Trendy Table Hotspots Comfort Food Classics
Made In New York Pizza on Amsterdam specializes in ultra-crisp square slices with cupping pepperoni and a balanced, slightly sweet sauce, plus classic round pies. Locals treat it as a modern UWS slice benchmark, especially for quick dinners and late-night cravings.
Must-Try Dishes: Spicy pepperoni square slice, Classic cheese slice, White square slice
Scores:
Value: 8.4 Service: 7.4 Consistency: 8.6 Food Quality: 9 Atmosphere: 6.8 Cultural Relevance: 8.3
What makes it special: Crisp-edged square slices with cupping pepperoni and balanced sauce.
Who should go: Slice obsessives chasing modern, Instagram-famous New York squares.
When to visit: Afternoons or late nights to avoid the heaviest lines.
What to order: Spicy pepperoni square, classic cheese slice, white square.
Insider tip: Stand at the counter for hottest trays as they land.