Skip to main content

Goodfellas Pizzeria of LIC
$ · Pizza

25-19 40th Ave, Long Island City, NY 11101
Are you the owner? Claim this business

ZipPicks Awards

Best Pizza in Long Island City Best Cheap Pizza in Long Island City

Vibe Check this spot

Food Quality 5
Service 5
Atmosphere 5
Value 5
Consistency 5
Cultural Relevance 5

0 / 5 selected

Master Critic Review

Goodfellas Pizzeria of LIC 8.2
Sunnyside
Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Late Night Legends Solo Dining Sanctuaries
A walk-up slice window built for fast satisfaction: thin, crisp-to-chewy New York slices that hit hardest when they’re fresh and hot. Skip over-ordering—two slices each plus one specialty slice for the table keeps the experience tight and still lets you sample range.
Must-Try Dishes: Cheese slice, Pepperoni slice, Specialty slice (rotating)
Scores:
Value: 8.1 Service: 7.6 Consistency: 8.6 Food Quality: 8.3 Atmosphere: 6.2 Cultural Relevance: 8
What makes it special: High-volume walk-up slices that stay crisp and classic.
Who should go: Slice people, late-night snack crews
When to visit: Late afternoon through late night
What to order: Cheese, pepperoni, one specialty slice
Insider tip: Ask what just came out—fresh slices are the whole point.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking only; limited metered spots nearby and can be tough after 6pm. Best accessed on foot or via nearby subway stops.
Dress code: Ultra-casual — anything goes. This is a walk-up slice spot, not a sit-down meal.
Noise level: High — street noise and kitchen bustle; not designed for lingering conversation.
Weekend wait: 5–15 minutes depending on line; slices move fast even when busy.
Weekday lunch: No wait to 5 minutes typically.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — cheese and rotating vegetarian specialty slices are usually available.
Vegan options: Very limited — occasionally a vegan slice, but availability isn’t consistent.
Gluten-free options: No — traditional wheat-based NY-style pizza only.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if the goal is casual and fast — it’s more of a grab-a-slice-and-walk vibe than a sit-and-talk date.
Can I get a table without a reservation? There are no reservations and little to no seating — plan on standing or taking slices to go.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes for older kids who like pizza; no high chairs or kid-specific amenities, but it’s quick and informal.
Best For
Better for: Late-night slices, fast turnaround, and budget-friendly New York–style pizza that hits when it’s fresh.
Skip if: You want sit-down dining, quieter conversation, or specialty diets like gluten-free or vegan.